greg (grysar) wrote,

The trouble with consultants.

Rolling Stone has a big expose on Democratic consultants. Two 2003 articles hit similar themes: Exit Poll by Noam Scheiber and Fire the Consultants by Amy Sullivan.

Key quotes:

While their GOP counterparts work for a flat fee on presidential campaigns, Democratic media consultants profit on commission, pocketing as much as ten percent of every dollar spent on TV ads. It's a business model that creates "an inherent conflict of interest," concedes Anita Dunn, who served as a strategist for Bill Bradley in 2000.
"Consulting," says former Gore campaign chair Tony Coelho, "is a business that can turn into a racket." Over the past two presidential elections, Rolling Stone estimates, that racket has cost the Democrats at least $10 million more in consultant fees than it did the Republicans.

Obviously the economics incentive structures here are way screwed up. A while back I did watch "Our Brand is Revolution," in which American consultants did try to help in Bolivia's elections. They were able to get a candidate in office in good part by skillfully out-maneuvering the other side. Although he squeaked through a multi-candidate election and ended up without enough of a mandate to succeed. So I do believe that the consultants can beat the crap out of candidates without the same level of firepower, but against the Republicans they haven't done a great job. I'm not sure how much the situation improved in 2006, although there was much more emphasis on the politicians heading various election committees, guys like Rahm Emaneul.

I think this also gets to an issue a one-time candidate friend of mine raised. Bases vote on policy but swing voters often vote on personality. Fine-tuning perfect messages for Dem presidential candidate seems to often come at the cost of personality. Personality is a often a terrible proxy for governing ability, but that's a different problem.

Hat Tip: Bradford Plumer on TNR's Plank.
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.